| Name |
Team |
Year |
| Paul Lisse |
Small College |
1926 |
| Clarence Wing |
Small College |
1932 |
| Norm Schoen |
Small College |
1937 |
| Jim Tyree |
Small College |
1954 |
| Obie Bender |
Methodist Small College |
1962 |
| Tom Goosby |
Methodist Small College |
1962 |
| John Halter |
Methodist Small College |
1962 |
| Obie Bender |
NAIA Small College |
1962 |
| Tom Goosby |
NAIA Small College |
1962 |
| Tom Goosby |
Methodist Small College |
1963 |
| Larry Shinn |
Methodist Small College |
1963 |
| Bob Quackenbush |
NAIA Small College |
1968 |
| Vern Shaubaugh |
NAIA Small College |
1968 |
| Tom Graham |
American Football Coaches Association |
1971 |
| Mark Summers |
Associated Press Little |
1974 |
| Roger Andrachik |
American Football Coaches Association |
1978 |
| Paul Petrella |
American Football Coaches Association |
1978 |
| Jeff Jenkins |
American Football Coaches Association |
1978 |
| Paul Petrella |
Associated Press Little |
1978 |
| Jeff Jenkins |
Associated Press Little |
1978 |
| Fred Buchanan |
Associated Press Little |
1978 |
| Tom Kelsey |
Associated Press Little |
1979 |
| Dan Delfino |
Associated Press Little |
1980 |
| Chuck Krajcic |
American Football Coaches Association |
1981 |
| Pete Primeau |
American Football Coaches Association |
1981 |
| Pete Primeau |
American Football Coaches Association |
1982 |
| Steve Varga |
American Football Coaches Association |
1982 |
| Jeff Rutherford |
Pizza Hut |
1983 |
| Steve Varga |
American Football Coaches Association |
1983 |
| Rick Newsock |
Football News |
1984 |
| Kert Boedicker |
Pizza Hut |
1984 |
| David Miller |
Pizza Hut |
1984 |
| Brian Moore |
Pizza Hut |
1984 |
| Kert Boedicker |
Football News |
1985 |
| Kert Boedicker |
Pizza Hut |
1985 |
| David Miller |
Pizza Hut |
1985 |
| John Price |
Pizza Hut |
1985 |
| Mark Schwertner |
Pizza Hut |
1985 |
| Phil Trupo |
Pizza Hut |
1985 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Associated Press Little |
1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller |
Associated Press Little |
1986 |
| Jeff Welcsh |
Associated Press Little |
1986 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Football News |
1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller |
Football News |
1986 |
| Jeff Welcsh |
Football News |
1986 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Pizza Hut |
1986 |
| Chris Riemenschneider |
Pizza Hut |
1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller |
Pizza Hut |
1986 |
| Lorne Conyers |
Associated Press Little |
1987 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Associated Press Little |
1987 |
| Greg Profancik |
Associated Press Little |
1987 |
| Dirk Riemenschneider |
Associated Press Little |
1987 |
| Jerry Sponseller |
Associated Press Little |
1987 |
| Lorne Conyers |
Football News |
1987 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Football News |
1987 |
| Wade Massad |
Football News |
1987 |
| Greg Profancik |
Football News |
1987 |
| Dirk Riemenschneider |
Football News |
1987 |
| Lorne Conyers |
Pizza Hut |
1987 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Pizza Hut |
1987 |
| Greg Profancik |
Pizza Hut |
1987 |
| Doug Haubert |
Associated Press Little |
1988 |
| Matt Kubinski |
Associated Press Little |
1988 |
| Wade Massad |
Associated Press Little |
1988 |
| Phil Medvetz |
Associated Press Little |
1988 |
| Scott Wilson |
Associated Press Little |
1988 |
| Shawn Gorman |
Football News |
1988 |
| Matt Kubinski |
Football News |
1988 |
| Wade Massad |
Football News |
1988 |
| Phil Medvetz |
Football News |
1988 |
| Erik Young |
Football News |
1988 |
| Doug Haubert |
Pizza Hut |
1988 |
| Wade Massad |
Pizza Hut |
1988 |
| Phil Medvetz |
Pizza Hut |
1988 |
| Scott Wilson |
Pizza Hut |
1988 |
| Doug Haubert |
American Football Coaches Association |
1989 |
| Doug Haubert |
Associated Press Little |
1989 |
| Dan Andrews |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1989 |
| Chuck Geiss |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1989 |
| Doug Haubert |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1989 |
| Phil Medvetz |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1989 |
| Dan Andrews |
Pizza Hut |
1989 |
| Doug Haubert |
Pizza Hut |
1989 |
| Phil Medvetz |
Pizza Hut |
1989 |
| Mike Laubacher |
Associated Press Little |
1990 |
| Mike Laubacher |
Champion-USA |
1990 |
| Mike Rodak |
Champion-USA |
1990 |
| Colin Johnson |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1990 |
| Mike Laubacher |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1990 |
| Mike Rodak |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1990 |
| Bob Anderson |
Champion-USA |
1991 |
| Jim Clardy |
Champion-USA |
1991 |
| Mike Barbetta |
Champion-USA |
1991 |
| John Koz |
Champion-USA |
1991 |
| Tom Serdinak |
Champion-USA |
1991 |
| Mike Barbetta |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1991 |
| Jim Clardy |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1991 |
| John Koz |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1991 |
| Jim Clardy |
Champion-USA |
1992 |
| Tom Garfield |
Champion-USA |
1992 |
| John Koz |
Champion-USA |
1992 |
| Jim Clardy |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1992 |
| Tom Garfield |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1992 |
| John Koz |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1992 |
| Gus Patouhas |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1992 |
| Kevin Stedman |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1992 |
| Lance Yandell |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1992 |
| Bill Linder |
Champion-USA |
1993 |
| Scott Hershiser |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1993 |
| John Koz |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1993 |
| Bill Linder |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1993 |
| Phil Sahley |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1993 |
| Lance Yandell |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1993 |
| Chris Kondik |
Associated Press Little |
1994 |
| Phil Sahley |
Associated Press Little |
1994 |
| Jason Klein |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1994 |
| Chris Kondik |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1994 |
| Phil Sahley |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1994 |
| Chris Kondik |
NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors |
1994 |
| Tony Oden |
NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors |
1994 |
| Phil Sahley |
NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors |
1994 |
| Phil Sahley |
Schooner's Coaches Association |
1994 |
| Fred Saylor |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1996 |
| Fred Saylor |
Hewlett-Packard |
1996 |
| Chris Kondik |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1997 |
| Fred Saylor |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
1997 |
| Chris Kondik |
Hewlett-Packard |
1997 |
| Fred Saylor |
Hewlett-Packard |
1997 |
| Mike Blackburn |
Hewlett-Packard |
1998 |
| Joe Dobies |
Hewlett-Packard |
2000 |
| Matt Caine |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2001 |
| Greg Koch |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2002 |
| Greg Koch |
Hewlett-Packard |
2002 |
| Greg Koch |
American Football Coaches Association |
2003 |
| Mark Anders |
D3football.com |
2003 |
| Greg Koch |
D3football.com |
2003 |
| Nate Mitchell |
D3football.com |
2003 |
| Nate Wilder |
D3football.com |
2003 |
| Mark Anders |
NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors |
2003 |
| Ian Formaz |
NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors |
2003 |
| Nate Mitchell |
NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors |
2003 |
| Mark Anders |
Associated Press Little |
2004 |
| Ian Formaz |
Associated Press Little |
2004 |
| Greg Koch |
Associated Press Little |
2004 |
| Nate Mitchell |
Associated Press Little |
2004 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
D3football.com |
2004 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2004 |
| Ryan Lewis |
D3football.com |
2005 |
| Joe George |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2005 |
| Ryan Lewis |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2005 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
Associated Press Little |
2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
D3football.com |
2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
D3football.com |
2007 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette |
2007 |
| Matt Harmon |
American Football Coaches Association |
2013 |
| Jason Cook |
D3football.com |
2013 |
| Matt Harmon |
D3football.com |
2013 |
| Patrick Simon |
American Football Coaches Association |
2021 (Fall) |
| Nick Pankow |
D3football.com |
2021 (Fall) |
| Patrick Simon |
D3football.com |
2021 (Fall) |
| Anthony Kendall |
American Football Coaches Association |
2022 |
| Anthony Kendall |
Associated Press |
2022 |
| Anthony Kendall |
D3football.com |
2022 |
